The March of Time / W. Howard Greene and Harold Rosson (1936)
Edgar Bergen / W. Howard Greene / Museum of Modern Art Film Library / Mack Sennett (1937)
J. Arthur Ball / والت ديزنى / Deanna Durbin and Mickey Rooney / Gordon Jennings, Jan Domela, Devereaux Jennings, Irmin Roberts, Art Smith, Farciot Edouart, Loyal Griggs, Loren L. Ryder, Harry D. Mills, Louis Mesenkop, Walter Oberst / Oliver T. Marsh and Allen Davey / Harry Warner (1938)
Douglas Fairbanks / Judy Garland / William Cameron Menzies / Motion Picture Relief Fund (Jean Hersholt, Ralph Morgan, Ralph Block, Conrad Nagel)/ Technicolor Company (1939)
والت ديزنى, William Garity, John N. A. Hawkins, and the RCA Manufacturing Company / Leopold Stokowski and his associates / Rey Scott / British Ministry of Information (1941)
دورا تشامبرلين / Ira and Rita Katzenberg / Jules Leventhal / Burns Mantle / P. A. MacDonald / Vincent Sardi Sr. (1947)
Vera Allen / Paul Beisman / Joe E. Brown / Cast of The Importance of Being Earnest / Robert W. Dowling / Experimental Theatre Inc. / Rosalind Gilder / June Lockhart / مارى مارتين / George Pierce / James Whitmore (1948)
No award (1949)
Maurice Evans / Philip Faversham / Brock Pemberton (1950)
Fourth Street Chekov Theatre / City Center / The New York Public Library Theatre Collection / The Shakespearewrights / The Threepenny Opera (1956)
American Shakespeare Festival / Jean-Louis Barrault / Robert Russell Bennett / William Hammerstein / Joseph Harbuck / Paul Shyre (1957)
Mrs. Martin Beck / New York Shakespeare Festival (1958)
Russel Crouse and Howard Lindsay / John Gielgud / Cast of La Plume de Ma Tante (1959)
Burgess Meredith and James Thurber / John D. Rockefeller III (1960)
David Merrick / The Theatre Guild (1961)
Brooks Atkinson / Richard Rodgers / Franco Zeffirelli (1962)
الان بيننيت, Peter Cook, Jonathan Miller and Dudley Moore / Irving Berlin / W. McNeil Lowry (1963)
Eva Le Gallienne (1964)
Gilbert Miller / Oliver Smith (1965)
Helen Menken (1966)
No award (1967)
APA-Phoenix Theatre / Pearl Bailey / Carol Channing / Maurice Chevalier / Marlene Dietrich / اودرى هيبورن / David Merrick (1968)
Leonard Bernstein / كارول بيرنت / ريكس هاريسون / The National Theatre Company of Great Britain / The Negro Ensemble Company (1969)
Noël Coward / Lynn Fontanne and Alfred Lunt / New York Shakespeare Festival / باربرا سترايساند (1970)
Ingram Ash / Elliot Norton / Playbill / Roger L. Stevens (1971)
Fiddler on the Roof / ايثيل ميرمان / Richard Rodgers / The Theatre Guild-American Theatre Society (1972)
The Actors Fund of America / John Lindsay / Shubert Organization (1973)
Actors' Equity Association / A Moon for the Misbegotten / Candide / Peter Cook and Dudley Moore / Harold Friedlander / بيت ميدلر / لايزا مينيلى / Theatre Development Fund / John F. Wharton (1974)
Al Hirschfeld (1975)
1976–2000
George Abbott / ريتشارد بيرتون / Circle in the Square Theatre / Thomas H. Fitzgerald / Mathilde Pincus (1976)
Cheryl Crawford / Equity Liberty Theatre / Barry Manilow / National Theatre of the Deaf / Diana Ross / ليلى توملين (1977)
Irving Berlin / Stan Dragoti and Charles Moss (1978)
Walter F. Diehl / Eugene O'Neill Memorial Theater Center / هنرى فوندا / Richard Rodgers (1979)